THREAD: Kinect vs. Move vs. Wii
  1. 11-15-2010, 02:19 AM
    schaffinosx's Avatar
    schaffinosx
    To and fro the island.
    schaffinosx's Avatar
    schaffinosx
    To and fro the island.
    2,173
    Posts
    9,586
    Reputation
    Dec 2009
    NextGenUpdate
    Kinect vs. Move vs. Wii
    Written by SchaffinOSX (Reporter)

    With the Kinect finally having released, it is time for us to step back and analyze each product. Of course, in the months to come there will be heated debate concerning which is the best, and like with the console-wars, no one will ever "officially" win. Putting all fanboy arguments aside, however, hopefully we can look at the facts, and come to a more logical conclusion as to which device is, overall, the best.

    So, let us begin:

    Price

    Kinect - Assuming you already own an Xbox 360 console, the base package of the Kinect will cost you £129.99. Some may argue that it is too expensive. However, if you consider that you only need that much to support as many players as you'd like, the price immediately seems better.

    Move - The cheapest thing on this list: £29.99. However, you can't buy the controller, go home, and just start playing. You'll also need a PlayStation Eye. Purchasing both the controller and PlayStation Eye will set you back about £44.99. The quality of the controllers make them well worth the value, but unfortunately, if you want to play with others, you'll have to purchase more controllers.

    Wii - The Wii currently costs around £149.99. Chances are that if you want a Wii, you already have one. Although it may not quite stack up against the Kinect of the PlayStation Move, the demographics for the Wii console include a hell of a lot of people, despite what some may say.

    Accuracy

    Kinect - In terms of realtime movement capture, the Kinect fails in comparison to the PlayStation Move. However, the Kinect and PlayStation Move don't exactly use motion control in the same way, and henceforth comparing the two should be out of the question in this regards. The Kinect is about full body control and broad sweeping motions; both of which the Kinect does very well.

    Move - Give Sony a pat on the back. The PlayStation Move isn't just a Wii copycat. In fact, it's better in regards to accuracy. When you move your Move controller, the in-game avatar will do the same in realtime, and exactly as you did it. It certainly opens doors to limitless possibilites, and actually boils down to someone's physical skill. For some that's good news, for others, the Move is just another way to try and make us exercise.

    Wii - Although the Wii was the pioneer that set this all in motion (no pun intended), it doesn't stack up against the Kinect or Move. The Wii uses pre-set animations, meaning when you swipe the controller, the character does something essentially the same to what you did, but without taking into consideration the way you did it. The Wii Motion Plus has resolved this to some extent, but still is far from stacking up to that of the PlayStation Move.

    Setup

    Kinect - Despite that some have deemed the Kinect's setup to be utter hell, this source seems to think otherwise: "[W]e have one in the NowGamer office and we play it in a small room with dim lighting and lots of furniture and it works perfectly fine 100 per cent of the time. Kinect takes a bit of calibration sure, but it works fine for us." Unless NowGamer has a Kinect unlike all others, I think it's safe to say that the setup is fairly simplistic.

    Move - The Move, being as precise as it is, requires users to calibrate it each time you play each and every game. Although that sounds like a big inconvenience, it really isn't. You either A.) Point your Move controller at the PlayStation Eye for five seconds, or B.) Lift and Lower the controller so that it frames you properly. Then you're done! Thankfully, the Move isn't very space sensitive.

    Wii - Very easy to setup. However, it seems as though plenty of people don't understand certain details of getting started. When the Wii first released, many parents who had gotten their children the console returned it, claiming they had been given a faulty product. You may think you understand it, but hey, check the manual if something isn't working the way you think.

    Software

    Kinect - As with its competitors, the Kinect reaches out to the more casual gaming market, with titles like Kinectimals, Dance Central, and Kinect: Sports launching on day one. There has been much talk about "phase two" of the Kinect, however, which has brought up the combination of pad and motion control. Another gaming revolution o the way?

    Move - Currently, the Move has the widest horizon when it comes to games compatible the the PlayStation Move. With games such as Tumble, Sports Champions, and Start the Party already having been released, and the promising future of Killzone 3 and the Sly Collection, it seems Move owners are in for quite a new, and enjoyable experience.

    Wii - Although many argue that the Wii has no good games out there, there are quite a few recommended titles out there for Wii owners to look at: Metroid Prime Trilogy, No More Heroes, Madworld, Okami, New Super Mario Bros, Metroid: Other M, Wario World: The Shake Dimension, The Legend Of Zelda: Twilight Princess, Resident Evil 4, Resident Evil Archives, Tatsunoko Vs Capcom and of course, Super Mario Galaxy.

    Verdict

    As of now, it would seem that the PlayStation Move is the best buy. However, the Kinect has just come out, and its future is bright. In the coming weeks and months, this verdict could change entirely. The real winner here isn't the PlayStation Move, though, but the gamers of the world. Never before have the horizons for gaming been so great, and although the PlayStation Move is the best buy at this time, the Wii, Kinect, and Move are all brilliant devices.

    It's a great time to be a gamer.

    Source: You must login or register to view this content. & N4G
  2. The Following 17 Users Say Thank You to schaffinosx For This Useful Post:

    , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  3. 04-11-2011, 03:05 PM
    1,072
    Posts
    1,534
    Reputation
    Mar 2010
    NextGenUpdate
    Like everyone else is saying...Kinect = No controller!
  4. 04-16-2011, 06:51 PM
    domba's Avatar
    domba
    Brute
    domba's Avatar
    domba
    Brute
    228
    Posts
    147
    Reputation
    Apr 2011
    NextGenUpdate
    PlayStation Move FTW!
  5. 04-26-2011, 12:39 AM
    60
    Posts
    19
    Reputation
    Aug 2010
    NextGenUpdate
    if the wiis games were better wii would be better

    ---------- Post added at 08:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:37 PM ----------

    Originally Posted by domba View Post
    PlayStation Move FTW!


    lol playstation move is okay it could of been better though
  6. 04-27-2011, 04:05 AM
    PhYzIcX's Avatar
    PhYzIcX
    Bounty hunter
    PhYzIcX's Avatar
    PhYzIcX
    Bounty hunter
    194
    Posts
    44
    Reputation
    Dec 2009
    NextGenUpdate
    The kinect seems like it has many more uses than for just gaming. The netflix compatibility seems cool by using gestures to control play/pause, and voice commands. These are things the move and wii cannot do.